Compass Cay Marina
Conch Cut
Joe Cay Cut
Pirate Trap Beach
Crescent Beach
Swim beside the docile nurse sharks gathered at the marina docks
Hike to Compass Peak, the island’s highest point
Snorkel the coral-fringed lagoon at Pirate Trap Beach
Beachcomb Crescent Beach’s half-mile curve of sand
Tender through Joe Cay Cut or Conch Cut to explore the neighbouring cays
Compass Cay Marina
Crescent Beach
Compass Peak
Pirate Trap Beach
Conch Cut
March through July generally brings the calmest water and the best visibility for swimming with the nurse sharks and snorkelling the surrounding flats, while the winter northers of December through February can push enough swell into the marina to make its open dockage uncomfortable. Summer stays warm but overlaps with hurricane season, so most charter itineraries build in flexibility around the forecast when this stop is on the route.
Compass Cay has no scheduled ferry or commercial flights of its own; a private sand airstrip exists but is usable only around low tide, so almost everyone arrives by boat. The nearest regular airport is Staniel Cay, a short cruise to the south, which most charter guests use to join or leave a yacht already under way through the Exumas.
Compass Cay Marina, inside one of the best-protected natural harbours in the Exumas, is the obvious choice for an overnight stay and gives direct access to the nurse shark encounter at the docks. Guests wanting a quieter alternative can anchor off Crescent Beach or Pirate Trap Beach in settled conditions, both a short tender ride from the marina itself.
A single night or even a few hours is enough for most guests to swim with the sharks, walk to Compass Peak and enjoy one of the beaches, since the cay is small and largely undeveloped beyond the marina. It combines naturally with a longer stop further north in the Exuma Cays Land and Sea Park or south toward Staniel Cay.
Yes, when done as the marina intends: the sharks gathered at the docks are accustomed to people and generally docile, feeding along the bottom rather than showing any interest in swimmers. Guests are asked to wade rather than swim aggressively, avoid grabbing the sharks, and follow the dock staff’s guidance, particularly with children, since a nurse shark’s bite, while rare, is still a wild animal’s.
Tell us what you would like to know, and our team will respond with clear details on availability, specification, pricing and next steps.
